Hiring your first caregivers
Your first caregivers set the standard for everyone who follows, and clients judge the agency by the person who comes through their door. A clear, repeatable hiring process helps you choose well, treat every applicant the same way, and show later what you checked and when.
Your state decides a lot here: caregiver qualifications, training hours, background and registry checks, and sometimes health screenings. Look these up before you post the first job.
Before you post the job
Decide the roles
You may start with caregivers and do the office work yourself, then add office roles as you grow. Typical roles are caregiver or companion, personal care aide, scheduler or care coordinator, and administrator. Write a job description for each: the duties within your scope of services, the physical demands, the schedule, and the qualifications your state requires.
Set pay and pay practices
Decide the pay rate for each role and service, how you pay for travel between clients, mileage, and any premium pay. Check the current federal and state rules on minimum wage, overtime and paid travel time before you set these. The Department of Labor's home care pages are the place to start on the federal side, and your state's labor agency covers the rest.
Your pay rate feeds straight into what each caregiver hour costs you. The bill rate calculator shows the effect before you commit.
Employees or contractors
The UnitAndLedger templates are written for agencies whose caregivers are employees. If you plan to treat caregivers as independent contractors, or to run a registry or referral model, get legal advice first. Many policies, forms and pay practices change.
Posting and screening
The job posting. Say what the job is: the duties, the schedule, the pay range, the area you cover and how to apply. Keep it about the job. Leave out anything about age, family, religion or other personal traits, and have your attorney look at the wording once.
The application. Collect what you need to decide whether the person can do the job and to run the checks your state requires: contact details, work history, availability, transportation, certifications if your state requires them, and references.
The phone screen. Ten to fifteen minutes, the same questions for everyone: availability, transportation, experience, why home care, and whether the pay and schedule work for them. It saves a long interview with someone who cannot work the hours you need.
Interviews that compare people fairly
Use the same questions for every candidate for the same job, and score each answer against a written description of a strong answer. A 1-to-5 scale is enough. Scoring as you go stops the last person you met from feeling like the best.
Use real situations from home care, for example:
- A client refuses a bath. What do you do?
- A client offers you $50 as a thank-you. What do you do?
- You arrive and the client does not answer the door. What do you do?
Strong answers respect the client's choices, follow the care plan, tell the office, and stay within the caregiver's role.
Ask only what you need to decide whether the person can do the job. Stay away from questions about health, age, pregnancy or family plans, religion and similar topics, and ask your attorney what federal and state law allow before and after an offer.
References. Call at least two, ask the same questions each time, and write down the answers. Ask about reliability, how the person treated clients, and whether the reference would hire them again.
Offer, checks and new hire paperwork
Conditional offer. Make the offer in writing and make it depend on the checks your state requires and your own policy calls for.
Background checks. Your state decides which checks and registries apply to caregivers. If you use a screening company, ask it which permissions and notices federal and state law require before a check and before you turn someone down because of a report, and follow its process.
Federal forms. Two points apply to every new employee:
- USCIS says: "All employers must complete and retain Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification, for every person they hire for employment after Nov. 6, 1986, in the U.S. as long as the person works for pay or other type of payment." (USCIS)
- The IRS says: "Ask all new employees to give you a signed Form W-4 when they start work." (IRS)
Your payroll provider can tell you which state forms and reports apply.
The personnel file. Use a checklist so every file holds the same things: the application, interview notes, reference checks, check results, signed agreements, training records and reviews.
Orientation and training before the first solo visit
Orientation is where caregivers learn how your agency works. Cover at least:
- Your scope of tasks: what caregivers may do, and what they never do.
- Client rights, dignity and professional boundaries, including gifts and money.
- Confidentiality and phones, photos and social media.
- How to clock in and out, and how to write a visit note.
- When and how to report a change in a client, an incident or a suspicion of abuse.
- Emergencies, home safety and fall prevention.
- Infection control: hand hygiene, gloves, cleaning and food safety.
Give each new caregiver the employee handbook and collect a signed acknowledgment.
Then check skills by watching them, not just by a quiz: hand washing, putting on and removing gloves, helping with a transfer, personal care help, safe meal preparation and a home safety check. Write down who was checked, by whom, on what date, and the result.
Your state may set minimum training hours, required topics and who may train. Keep a record that shows each caregiver met them.
When you can, introduce the caregiver to the client in person and arrange a shadow visit before the first shift alone.
The first 90 days
The first weeks are when problems are easiest to spot and fix. Plan short check-ins at 30, 60 and 90 days:
- How are the shifts, the clients and the travel?
- What has been hard? What would help?
- What do clients and the supervisor say?
- Is any training due?
Pair the check-ins with supervisory visits to the client's home. Fix small problems early and write down what you agreed.
Keep records
Keep personnel records for as long as federal and state rules require, and ask your attorney what that is for each type of record. Keep applications from people you did not hire too, and store everything where only the people who need it can see it.
Research and drafting are AI-assisted. Federal facts are quoted from the agency's own page, linked beside them; check them again before you rely on them, as rules change.